Elite Collection of Space Memorabilia, Including Apollo 11-Flown American Flag, Touches Down at Heritage Auctions
Lots from astronaut Fred Haise and Wright Flyer relics also among December 6-7 event highlights
An out-of-this-world collection of flown space memorabilia — arguably the world's finest ever assembled by anyone other than an astronaut — will touch down in Heritage's Space Exploration Signature Auction Dec. 6-7, 2024.
"The collection Jacques Bracke put together is absolutely incredible, and there will be more to come in future auctions at Heritage," says Brad Palmer, Director of Space Exploration at Heritage Auctions. "This auction focuses on items in the collection that actually flew into space, many of which have not reached the collecting market in decades. He built his collection through many avenues, including through previous auctions, but he also bought some directly from the astronauts themselves. The breadth and quality of his collection — he has flags, medallions, patches and even a Star Chart from Apollo 11 — is simply astounding."
Among the top attractions is an Apollo 11 Flown American Flag on a Crew-Signed Presentation Certificate that is signed by the mission's three astronauts. The 6-by-4-inch flag is mounted on a 10-by-12-inch certificate with the following printed text: "This Flag Traveled to the Moon with Apollo 11, the First Manned Lunar Landing, July 20, 1969/ APOLLO 11/ July 16-24, 1969/ Armstrong - Collins – Aldrin" and is signed beneath the printed mission insignia: "Neil Armstrong," "M Collins" and "Buzz Aldrin." Printed at the very bottom are the words Armstrong said in what is the most famous line in the history of space exploration: "One small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind."
One of the inarguably fascinating lots in the auction from the collection is an Apollo 11 Flown Command/Service Module Trans-Lunar Coast Star Chart Originally from the Personal Collection of Mission Lunar Module Pilot Buzz Aldrin, which comes with a signed certificate of authenticity. Titled "CSM TLC STAR CHART (B)/ LAUNCH JULY 21," it was specifically designed for use in the Command Module Columbia during the Apollo 11 mission to the moon. This museum-worthy chart, which has been in Bracke's collection since 2009, displays the Sun and planets as colored dots, standing out vividly against the star field to make them readily identifiable by the astronauts.
An Apollo 17 Flown Robbins Sterling Silver Medallion, Serial Number F38, Originally from the Personal Collection of Astronaut Joe Kerwin, was flown aboard Apollo 17, the 11th manned space mission in the NASA Apollo program. With a crew of Commander Eugene A. Cernan, Command Module Pilot Ronald E. Evans and Lunar Module Pilot Harrison H. "Jack" Schmitt, it also was the first night launch and the sixth and final lunar landing mission of the Apollo program. A total of 300 were minted to commemorate the mission but just 80 were flown, making this is the rarest of all Apollo silver Robbins medals.
The auction features a pair of lots of Flown Space Suit Patches from astronaut John Young. Thanks to his position aboard several Gemini and Apollo missions, as well as the Space Shuttle, Young is acknowledged as one of the most prolific of all American astronauts. One of the lots is a signed, framed display of Four Flown Space Suit Patches from Apollo 10 that includes (top to bottom) a U.S. flag measuring 5-3/4 by 3-3/4 inches, a NASA logo on Beta cloth (worn on the right chest), an Apollo 10 mission insignia on Bega cloth (worn on the left chest) and his "J. YOUNG" Beta cloth name patch (worn on middle chest). Also in play is a signed, framed display of Three Flown Space Suit Patches from Gemini 10, a prize that includes (top to bottom) a 5-1/4-by-4-inch U.S. flag, an embroidered Jemini 10 mission insignia patch and Young's "J.W. YOUNG" name patch (worn on right chest). Patches that come directly from an astronaut's space suit are coveted by collectors because of the difficulty in acquiring them. Both of these lots fit that criteria, and come from Young's personal collection.
Items that have been to space and owned by astronauts always generate significant interest among collectors, and that holds true with the auction's 20 lots from Personal Collection of Fred Haise. If not for a nearly catastrophic explosion, crew members Haise and James Lovell — would have had their names added to the list of 12 who have walked on the moon. A little more than two days into the mission — and more than 200,000 miles from home — Haise was completing a routine stirring of the oxygen tanks when members of the crew heard an explosion from the Service Module's oxygen tank, the ramifications of which included an interruption for several seconds of communication back to Earth. With oxygen in short supply, the decision was made to bring the vessel home, shortening the trip by some 36 hours and canceling the lunar landing.
Among the lots in the auction from Haise's collection is an Apollo 13 Lunar Module Aquarius Flown Translation Control Assembly T-Handle Controller. The Translation Control Assembly (TCA) allowed for precise manual control of the lunar module's translation-its linear movements along the X, Y and Z axes during spaceflight, utilizing a series of thrusters for positioning. This specific controller was operated by the astronauts to command reaction control system (RCS) jets for pitch, yaw, roll and linear translation, allowing the Lunar Module to maneuver during docking, undocking, descent and ascent phases. Following the Service Module oxygen tank explosion, the crew's ability to manually control the LM Aquarius became critical, and the lunar module was repurposed as a "lifeboat" to support the crew of Apollo 13.
Also from the Haise collection is an Apollo 13 Lunar Module Aquarius-Flown Flashlight. The explosion and subsequent aborting of the mission had altered plans to salvage various pieces of hardware from the Lunar Module LM-7 or Aquarius, and a flashlight was one of those items that Haise used for most of four days to provide lighting. With the extreme power down there was little spacecraft lighting available. The offered flashlight is the one used on Apollo 13 and has been in Haise's personal space artifact collection since 1970. It represents an extraordinary link to one of NASA's most challenging missions, with the poignant inscription "LIT MY WAY HOME" echoing the pivotal role such equipment played in ensuring the astronauts' safe return. This is the first time this unique artifact has been offered publicly.
One of the fascinating lots that will be available is a Moon Globe Signed by 27 NASA Astronauts, Three Soviet Cosmonauts, Two Pilots of SpaceShipOne and Two Space Film Actors. This 12-inch Replogle Lunar Globe with plastic base is signed by an array of spaceflight personnel, with each Moonlanding mission member's signature on the side of the moon on which he landed, as well as all three cosmonaut signatures appearing on the "Dark Side" of the globe. Among the most famous names inscribed on the globe are Walt Cunningham ("Apollo 7"); Buzz Aldrin ("Apollo XI"); Michael Collins ("Apollo XI CMP"); Alan Bean ("Apollo 12"); Richard Gordon ("Apollo XII"); James Lovell ("Gemini 7 PLT, Gemini 12 CDR, Apollo 8 CMP, Apollo 13 CDR … and has also written "Houston, we have a problem!"); Haise; Charlie Duke ("Apollo 16") and Gene Cernan ("Apollo XVII").
Other top lots in the auction include, but are not limited to:
posted 11-24-2024 10:17 AM
Who was Jacques Bracke? I wish we had known him.
cosmos-walter Member
Posts: 855 From: Salzburg, Austria Registered: Jun 2003
posted 11-24-2024 10:58 AM
Jacques Bracke from Bruges, Belgium was born on 10.07.1941 and died on 11.10.1923. He was a kind, generous person and amassed one of the most comprehensive astrophiliate collections ever to exist.
I remeber quite well when he showed me Brugge on a boat tour when I exhibited at Belgica 2001. Later, I organized that cosmonauts on board of the International Space Station wrote letters to him.
Axman Member
Posts: 630 From: Derbyshire UK Registered: Mar 2023
posted 11-24-2024 01:16 PM
OK, these might sound like really stupid questions, but I need to ask them.
Are Heritage Auctions reliable trustworthy and established?
Are all the links in the opening post directly connected to Heritage Auctions?
How do you bid live on any of the items (as opposed to the pre-auction internet option given on the website)?
Robert Pearlman Editor
Posts: 53647 From: Houston, TX Registered: Nov 1999
posted 11-24-2024 02:25 PM
From their own description:
Heritage Auctions is the largest fine art and collectibles auction house founded in the United States, and the world’s largest collectibles auctioneer. Heritage maintains offices in New York, Dallas, Beverly Hills, Chicago, Palm Beach, London, Paris, Amsterdam, Brussels, Hong Kong and Tokyo.
Yes, they are well established. Relevant to our own community, they were selected to handle the Armstrong Family collection after Neil Armstrong's his death in 2012.
All of the links in the press release are original to Heritage as provided by the auction house.
In addition to bidding in-person or by phone, online proxy bidding ends ten minutes prior to the session start time. Live Proxy bidding on Heritage Live (the same website) starts within two hours of when the auction opens for proxy bidding and continues through the live session.
Larry McGlynn Member
Posts: 1447 From: Boston, MA Registered: Jul 2003
posted 11-24-2024 07:13 PM
Thanks for the information Walter. I wish I had met him. At least I would have known who I was bidding against on a few different items.
cosmos-walter Member
Posts: 855 From: Salzburg, Austria Registered: Jun 2003
posted 11-25-2024 03:14 AM
At Heritage I was able to purchase one of only three hand painted covers that landed on the Moon with Apollo 16 at a very reasonable price.
Larry McGlynn Member
Posts: 1447 From: Boston, MA Registered: Jul 2003
posted 11-25-2024 07:41 PM
I remember those covers from Charlie Duke. I believe that Dr. Bill Hanson painted the covers.
CJ Member
Posts: 98 From: Cherry Hill, NJ Registered: Nov 2003
posted 11-25-2024 09:56 PM
Heritage Auctions has an interesting space camera lot #50179 listed as Hasselblad 500c Vintage Camera, Modified for Spaceflight.
The Zeiss 80mm Planar lens was manufactured in 1980 and doesn't have the modifications that were made to similar flown lenses on Mercury and Gemini missions. If NASA purchased this lens in 1980 it would not have been for this camera body.
The film magazine was manufactured in 1965, and the camera body was manufactured in 1968. In 1968, NASA was well past using the modifications made for Mercury and Gemini on any flight camera for Apollo.
SpaceBP New Member
Posts: 2 From: Registered: Apr 2023
posted 11-26-2024 11:15 AM
The description has been updated to reflect that it is unknown if this camera was used in any official capacity and is possibly modified for display purposes only.
cosmos-walter Member
Posts: 855 From: Salzburg, Austria Registered: Jun 2003
posted 11-27-2024 12:53 PM
quote:Originally posted by Larry McGlynn: I believe that Dr. Bill Hanson painted the covers.
Larry, you are right.
spaced out Member
Posts: 3218 From: Paris, France Registered: Aug 2003
posted 12-02-2024 07:03 AM
The Jacques Bracke collection is an extraordinary assembly of almost every known category of flown souvenir (flags, patches, medallions, covers etc) from pretty-much every Gemini and Apollo mission. I would say this is the most extensive offering of this kind of material I've ever seen in one auction.
Axman Member
Posts: 630 From: Derbyshire UK Registered: Mar 2023
posted 12-02-2024 08:12 AM
I've just sat down and gone through all 109 lots I could see on the webpage, and despite discarding all flags, medallions and non-philatelic items as well as the two items I already possess, my want list based on the minimum bids + buyers premium comes to a staggering $102,675.
I sadly cannot afford anything close to that amount, but I'm still hopeful I might yet acquire a cover (or even two). My next dilemma is how to strategise my bidding such that I don't invest all my baskets into a single golden egg some other bidder has already inscribed their name on...
GACspaceguy Member
Posts: 3130 From: Guyton, GA Registered: Jan 2006
posted 12-02-2024 08:33 AM
Understand the dilemma. Wanting something later in the auction but bid and won items earlier. By the time you get to that item and the price goes past what you expected you wish you had not won the earlier ones to allow for more money to be spent on the later item. Then if you do not win the later you wish you had not passed on the earlier ones you may have bid on.
For me I look at that special item and set an amount in my mind, once it goes past that number I will allow my self one maybe two bids then I walk away as too expensive for my taste. I try to have a second item down stream from that one in case I do not become the highest bidder on the first item.
Now if we can just figure a way of not outbidding each other.
stsmithva Member
Posts: 2107 From: Fairfax, VA Registered: Feb 2007
posted 12-05-2024 03:41 PM
I was interested to see one of the featured lots, "NASA Astronaut Group Two: Nine New Astronauts Report for Duty Cover Signed."
This is because the very first "premium" item I bought myself when I got big into "collecting space" in 2007 was one of those same covers, also signed by all nine of that amazing group. I am fortunate in that mine has the signatures in a neat column, all in the same pen. I picture them at a meeting or training session in late 1962, passing that cover and pen around.
rjurek349 Member
Posts: 1242 From: Northwest Indiana Registered: Jan 2002
posted 12-07-2024 12:13 PM
The prices realized in this auction were very strong, for the most part, which was good to see. As someone with a large flown space numismatic collection, I was pleased to see the realized prices on those items go well above my expectations. The GT4 1907 Liberty Head $2.5 gold piece from McDivitt at $16,500 (with fees) was thrilling to see. Congrats to the buyers, the sellers (especially Jacques family estate), and Heritage.
Robert Pearlman Editor
Posts: 53647 From: Houston, TX Registered: Nov 1999
Out-of-this-World Treasures from Elite Collection Lead Heritage's Space Exploration Auction Above $2.7 Million
Apollo 10 space suit patches, Apollo 11-flown American flag, trans-lunar chart among December 6-7 event highlights
Bidding interest soared for a signed, framed display of Four Flown Space Suit Patches from Apollo 10 that once belonged to an astronaut acknowledged as one of the most prolific in the history of the U.S. Space program. By the time the final bid landed, the display of patches from astronaut John Young more than quadrupled its pre-auction estimate when it sold for $137,500.
The out-of-this-world result for this magnificent lot led Heritage's December 6-7 Space Exploration Signature Auction to $2,737,584, thanks to eager participation by more than 1,500 bidders.
"John Young's name is sprinkled throughout the annals of the U.S. Space program," says Brad Palmer, Director of Space Exploration at Heritage Auctions. "The fact that this lot performed so well shows that Heritage Auctions' clients not only want items that belonged to astronauts, but they also understand the historical significance of Young and the missions on which he flew."
The display was one of more than more than 100 lots in this auction from the Family Collection of Jacques Bracke, a Belgian collector whose collection is considered one of the very finest in the world from a non-astronaut. More treasures from his collection will be offered through Heritage Auctions in future auctions. The lots selected for this auction revealed a focus on items that actually flew into space, many of which have not reached the collecting market in decades.
Also from the Bracke collection was an Apollo 11-Flown American Flag on a Crew-Signed Presentation Certificate that not only was aboard the first lunar landing mission, but also was signed by the three astronauts on board. The 6-by-4-inch flag, which bears the signatures of Neil Armstrong, Buzz Aldrin and Michael Collins, includes at the very bottom are the words Armstrong said in what is the most famous line in the history of space exploration: "One small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind." This magnificent keepsake more than doubled its estimate when it sold for $93,750.
The Bracke collection produced one of the auction's undeniably fascinating lots: an Apollo 11 Flown Command/Service Module Trans-Lunar Coast Star Chart Originally from the Personal Collection of Mission Lunar Module Pilot Buzz Aldrin that brought $68,750, more than doubling its pre-auction estimate. Titled "CSM TLC STAR CHART (B)/ LAUNCH JULY 21," it was specifically designed for use in the Command Module Columbia during the Apollo 11 mission to the moon. This museum-worthy chart, which has been in Bracke's collection since 2009, displays the Sun and planets as colored dots, standing out vividly against the star field to make them readily identifiable by the astronauts.
Items that have been flown to the Moon always generate interest, and that was the case for an Apollo 11-Flown American Flag Certified and Signed by Michael Collins, also from the Bracke collection, that more than doubled its pre-auction estimate when it drew a winning bid of $55,000. A 6-by-4-inch silk U.S. flag that flew aboard the Apollo 11 mission, Collins has signed on two of the lower white stripes in black ink: "Carried to the Moon on Apollo Eleven/ July 1969- Michael Collins CMP."
The Bracke collection yielded many of the treasures in the auction, but the event also featured selections from the collection of Apollo 13 astronaut Fred Haise, who was scheduled to become the sixth man to walk on the moon, a plan that changed after an explosion in the Service Module's oxygen tank. Among the lots from his collection was an Apollo 13 Lunar Module Aquarius-Flown Flashlight Directly from the Personal Collection of Lunar Module Pilot Fred Haise that shined brightly at $106,250, more than 10 times the pre-auction estimate. The explosion and subsequent aborting of the mission had altered plans to salvage various pieces of hardware from the Lunar Module LM-7 or Aquarius, and a flashlight was one of those items that Haise used for most of four days to provide lighting. With the extreme power down there was little spacecraft lighting available. This flashlight is the one used on Apollo 13 and has been in Haise's personal space artifact collection since 1970. It represents an extraordinary link to one of NASA's most challenging missions, with the poignant inscription "LIT MY WAY HOME."
One lucky bidder got a grip on an Apollo 13 Lunar Module Aquarius Flown Translation Control Assembly T-Handle Controller from Haise's collection for $55,000. The Translation Control Assembly (TCA) allowed for precise manual control of the lunar module's translation-its linear movements along the X, Y and Z axes during spaceflight, utilizing a series of thrusters for positioning. Following the Service Module oxygen tank explosion, the crew's ability to manually control the LM Aquarius became critical, and the lunar module was repurposed as a "lifeboat" to support the crew of Apollo 13.
Posts: 3218 From: Paris, France Registered: Aug 2003
posted 12-13-2024 04:56 AM
quote:Originally posted by rjurek349: The prices realized in this auction were very strong, for the most part, which was good to see.
Agreed. You might have thought such a huge amount of material in one auction might lead to weaker results but it seemed the opposite was the case.
Larry McGlynn Member
Posts: 1447 From: Boston, MA Registered: Jul 2003
posted 12-15-2024 09:52 AM
I wonder how much Bitcoin and its stratospheric rise contributed to the results?
spaced out Member
Posts: 3218 From: Paris, France Registered: Aug 2003
posted 12-16-2024 04:29 AM
I don't know, but in reality anyone who hasn't sold it hasn't actually made any money at this point.
By the way - I have some very valuable tulip bulbs that have been passed down in my family for a few generations if you're interested. Should be worth millions by now.
Larry McGlynn Member
Posts: 1447 From: Boston, MA Registered: Jul 2003
posted 12-16-2024 08:25 AM
While not involved in Bitcoin in anyway, the fact that Bitcoin is hovering at $103,000 USD per unit and that Heritage accepts Bitcoin for transactions of over $5,000, I wonder if people were offloading some of their "shares" to buy alternative assets or hard assets in order to convert some of the Bitcoin into something tangible for later resale. At the current value, even if money is lost in a resale, the owner will receive cash for the resale in the future.
Otherwise, what is to explain the outlier this auction's result has become based on the last three years? There may have been a different set of collectors, such as numismatists, but $106,000 for a penlight is extreme even in the hobby.
spaced out Member
Posts: 3218 From: Paris, France Registered: Aug 2003
posted 12-16-2024 10:10 AM
I do feel that the breadth of quality material in one auction may have boosted interested and hence results across the board.
I'm sure there were collectors with serious budgets who went through pushing bidding up on multiple items across the range pre-sale, then once they're in the live auction they don't want to come away with nothing so they push hard on multiple items until they win enough to burn their budget.
In the end most of these results look pretty solid to us, but for a few deep-pocketed collectors picking up multiple items in the low thousands is small change, so in an auction like this they can fill all the holes in their Fliteline or Robbins sets or the missing flown flags/patches/covers in one go. It was just a great opportunity.
MartinAir Member
Posts: 422 From: Registered: Oct 2020
posted 12-16-2024 05:43 PM
In my opinion, it was THE penlight and the highlight of the auction. Still, a bargain compared to the contemporary print signed by Jim Lovell, which sold for over $200K in another space auction...
Larry McGlynn Member
Posts: 1447 From: Boston, MA Registered: Jul 2003
posted 12-17-2024 08:20 PM
I have seen quality material is several auctions over the past five years. With the exception of Buzz Aldrin's 2022 auction at Sothebys, I have not seen sustained auction results in one space auction like this in the hobby in a long time. It was excellent material, but I have seen excellent material in several different auctions and the pricing on premium items was not up to this level.
That was the reason I posed the question, because just having good material doesn't completely answer the question of the pricing. I am happy with the results because it is saying that the hobby is strong. I would love some data about the sale from Heritage such as the number of registered bidders as well as some demographics on those bidders. While I know that information won't be forthcoming as that is private information known only to the auction houses. I would just love to gauge the extent of the market now.
As I said, I was just pondering the results. Like you, I track all the auctions and document the pricing. This auction was the best I have seen since 2022 and that was almost all about Apollo 11 material from Buzz Aldrin. Let's see what the near future holds.
rdm65 New Member
Posts: 4 From: Lincolnton, NC USA Registered: Feb 2014
posted 12-17-2024 08:52 PM
I won the auction for the right glove of Helen Sharman's Sokol glove in the auction. Does anyone know the story of how it became available on the private market?
SpaceAholic Member
Posts: 5416 From: Sierra Vista, Arizona Registered: Nov 1999
posted 12-17-2024 09:49 PM
Heritage doesn't offer any provenance to support the claim the glove was flown/used to and from orbit. Her complete flown suit with gloves was purchased by the British Science Museum Group and is on display in London.
Rick Mulheirn Member
Posts: 4604 From: England Registered: Feb 2001
posted 12-18-2024 03:23 AM
That piece had me wondering too. I don't know for sure, whether or how many spare gloves were carried on Sharman's flight but her flown suit (complete with gloves) is on display in the Science Museum, London.
Larry McGlynn Member
Posts: 1447 From: Boston, MA Registered: Jul 2003
posted 12-18-2024 07:12 PM
That glove has been making the rounds. Heritage sold the same glove in 2011 and 2017.
SpaceAholic Member
Posts: 5416 From: Sierra Vista, Arizona Registered: Nov 1999
posted 12-18-2024 09:00 PM
Left companion glove (2011 lot).
neo1022 Member
Posts: 332 From: Santa Monica, CA Registered: Jun 2013
posted 12-19-2024 11:10 AM
I was waiting for this thread to appear! I was looking into this issue when the catalog was first posted online. The serial number on the Heritage gloves is one digit off from the gloves with her flown suit (either higher or lower, can't remember).
I recall that each crew member received two pairs of gloves, but I'm not sure what that means in terms of flown status (I'll check on this). In any case, the Heritage glove was produced immediately before or after her mission-used gloves, so it's clearly directly associated with Sharman's flight and/or training.
Surprising that Heritage asserted flown status with no supporting evidence (and with the "prime" flown gloves housed in a museum with her suit...).